* FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Got general Family History research questions - this is the place
Post Reply
avatar
jbtapscott
Megastar
Posts: 513
Joined: 19 Nov 2014 17:52
Family Historian: V7
Location: Corfu, Greece
Contact:

FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by jbtapscott »

Over the last few weeks I have found a number of people in my tree who were born in Hong Kong circa 1890 (per Civil Service birth records, etc). After they returned to the UK I have found Census records for them, but the transcript of these on FMP shows Place of Birth as China, although the underlying / attached schedule clearly shows Hong Kong.

I have not taken this up with FMP yet, but surely a transcript should be exactly that rather than showing a "politically correct" version of a place - we don't see transcripts of documents referencing old English counties showing the modern name / location so surely the same should apply to countries. Just wondering what others think before I raise this with FMP.
Brent Tapscott ~ researching the Tapscott and Wallace family history
Tapscott & Wallace family tree
User avatar
ColeValleyGirl
Megastar
Posts: 5465
Joined: 28 Dec 2005 22:02
Family Historian: V7
Location: Cirencester, Gloucestershire
Contact:

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by ColeValleyGirl »

Is it definitely a transcript or is it an index?
avatar
jbtapscott
Megastar
Posts: 513
Joined: 19 Nov 2014 17:52
Family Historian: V7
Location: Corfu, Greece
Contact:

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by jbtapscott »

It is the transcript of a 1901 Census, with the attached image (the one listing a group of houses and the individuals in them) clearly showing Hong Kong as the place of birth.
Brent Tapscott ~ researching the Tapscott and Wallace family history
Tapscott & Wallace family tree
User avatar
David2416
Superstar
Posts: 398
Joined: 12 Nov 2017 16:37
Family Historian: V7
Location: Suffolk UK

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by David2416 »

FMP's transcripts include information that was not on the original image so are not a strict transcript
for example from 1851
Birth Place Marldon Devon becomes Marldon, Devon, England
Year of birth is added, occupation and infirmity are left out
Place Church Street Paington becomes Church Street, Paington, Totnes, Devon, England

To be consistent Hong Kong should perhaps become Hong Kong China?
User avatar
ColeValleyGirl
Megastar
Posts: 5465
Joined: 28 Dec 2005 22:02
Family Historian: V7
Location: Cirencester, Gloucestershire
Contact:

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by ColeValleyGirl »

David, thats why I suspect they shouldn't be viewed as transcripts but rather the terms from the original record that have been indexed (and normalised). I could be wrong.
User avatar
AdrianBruce
Megastar
Posts: 2090
Joined: 09 Aug 2003 21:02
Family Historian: V7
Location: South Cheshire
Contact:

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by AdrianBruce »

FMP's understanding of the word "Transcript" is not necessarily one we'd agree with. :( I tune out their word and substitute "Index"...
Adrian
User avatar
ColeValleyGirl
Megastar
Posts: 5465
Joined: 28 Dec 2005 22:02
Family Historian: V7
Location: Cirencester, Gloucestershire
Contact:

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by ColeValleyGirl »

Adrian, two minds with a single thought :D
User avatar
LornaCraig
Megastar
Posts: 3190
Joined: 11 Jan 2005 17:36
Family Historian: V7
Location: Oxfordshire, UK

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by LornaCraig »

On the other hand FMP themselves seem to think they are transcripts. When you report an error it says "We can only amend transcriptions where they fail to reflect what was actually written in the original record." (Their italics, not mine!)

So if they have transcribed/indexed (whatever you want to call it) Hong Kong as China they have not followed their own rules and anyone would be entirely justified in reporting this as an error.
Lorna
avatar
jbtapscott
Megastar
Posts: 513
Joined: 19 Nov 2014 17:52
Family Historian: V7
Location: Corfu, Greece
Contact:

Re: FMP Transcript of Birth Place - Hong Kong

Post by jbtapscott »

Interestingly when I chose the "Report an Error" option, the resulting screen showed "Birth Place" as China and, on the next row, "Birth Place other as transcribed" equal to Hong Kong!. I will now contact their customer services people to try and establish what this is supposed to mean, although I suspect I won't get far!.
Brent Tapscott ~ researching the Tapscott and Wallace family history
Tapscott & Wallace family tree
Post Reply