FHUG : Family Historian User Group

Wish List

Main Site  View Wishlist

Reference 479
Title Show Citation for Shared Notes in Reports
Category Reports
Description CLOSED - MERGED INTO WL#73

FH should show the citations relevant to a shared note that is printed in a report.
Why: (See mailing list "Citations for Shared Notes" 12/07/2011 onwards.)
Summarising from there:
I'm creating a shared note that I want accessed from one or more people.
I've created the shared note, with its own citations to various things like encyclopaedia entries, etc.
Then I link the shared note to a person and run off a narrative report for said person -
the shared note appears but the citations for the shared note don't appear.
If I copy the citations from the shared note to the person and apply them to the link
from the person to the shared note, then they will appear.
But that's
(a) a pointless duplication of citations and
(b) arguably wrong since the cited sources don't mention the individual at all.

Way forward:
Citations for shared notes should appear in reports as well as the contents of the shared note.
Where the shared notes appear at lower level (e.g. notes to media and to sources)
it would seem unnecessary to cite those notes, otherwise one might go on forever.
Why: (See mailing list "Citations for Shared Notes" 12/07/2011 onwards.)
Summarising from there:
I'm creating a shared note that I want accessed from one or more people.
I've created the shared note, with its own citations to various things like encyclopaedia entries, etc.
Then I link the shared note to a person and run off a narrative report for said person -
the shared note appears but the citations for the shared note don't appear.
If I copy the citations from the shared note to the person and apply them to the link
 from the person to the shared note, then they will appear.
But that's
(a) a pointless duplication of citations and
(b) arguably wrong since the cited sources don't mention the individual at all.

Way forward:
Citations for shared notes should appear in reports as well as the contents of the shared note.
Where the shared notes appear at lower level (e.g. notes to media and to sources)
it would seem unnecessary to cite those notes, otherwise one might go on forever.
Web Link http://www.fhug.org.uk/cgi-bin/index.cgi?action=forum&board=wishlist2&op=display&num=5228
Votes 5
Rating 3.6
Added Saturday 06th August 2011 12:00 PM
Last Vote Tuesday 11th September 2012 07:48 PM
Released in version 0.0 Dup

 

Only Signed in FHUG users can vote, please return to the main site and sign in.

 Return to List